I originally left a 5-star review because I was excited to work with 1-800-ACCOUNTANT. Unfortunately, after going through the entire process, I felt it was important to update my review to reflect my actual experience. From the beginning, I was passed from one representative to another, making it difficult to get consistent answers or build a relationship with anyone familiar with my account. I often found myself repeating the same information over and over. When my tax return was completed, the refund was much lower than expected. After reviewing the return myself, I discovered that legitimate business expenses had been left off entirely. I contacted the company, but I received conflicting information about whether those expenses could be deducted. It wasn’t until the return was corrected that my refund increased significantly. As a client, I shouldn’t have had to find a major error on my own. The bookkeeping experience was just as frustrating. I organized all of my expenses in a spreadsheet, only to be told to manually enter everything again into ClientBooks. I ended up doing much of the work I thought I was paying an accounting service to handle. Overall, the experience felt disorganized, communication was inconsistent, and I spent more time managing the process than receiving professional guidance. I hired 1-800-ACCOUNTANT because I wanted to simplify running my business, but instead it added stress and consumed valuable time. I hope they improve communication, quality control, and continuity between team members. I rarely write negative reviews, but I believe other small business owners deserve to know about my experience before making a decision.
About
1-800Accountant is a leading provider of accounting and tax services for small businesses in New York. Our team are dedicated to delivering tailored, year-round tax, bookkeeping, payroll and advisory support, ensuring compliance with local and state rules and providing clear, timely financial insight so clients can focus on growing their business.
Reviews
Based on 3792 Google reviews
Our Payroll Specialist, Kristin D and our Tax Advisor, Alice S are outstanding to work with. Any questions, they are right there with actionable help that makes sense instead of using industry jargon. Kristin is super friendly and helps me with payroll every pay period. Alice makes taxes actually make sense.
Niki was super helpful...as she aptly put it "I don't know what I don't know" which is an understatement. She put out a lot of information in a short time and it is very much appreciated. It was a very positive introduction to your services and guidance. I felt comfortable listening to her explain all the nuances of accounting and taxes. I look forward to using your services for my start-up business.
I would not recommend this company, especially to a new business owner. I paid over $4,000 for tax preparation and was extremely disappointed with the lack of professionalism, communication, and due diligence. The tax preparer repeatedly told me they did not have documents I had already provided. I had to argue with them before they actually reviewed my files and found the W-2 they claimed was missing. Several items supported by receipts were also left off my tax paperwork. I felt rushed through the process with little explanation or meaningful discussion. If you don't know the right questions to ask, they don't seem interested in telling you what you need to know. Managers failed to properly follow up, and I was told calls and voicemails were made that I never received. For what they charge, I expected much better service and attention to detail. The entire experience felt more like getting clients through the next appointment than actually helping them. Because my concerns were not properly addressed, I had to file a complaint with the state. Based on my experience, I would not recommend this company. 9/10 I reached out never responded back.
Promised tax filing and guidance; still unfiled six months later I paid approximately $3,600 in April 2026 for 1-800Accountant services covering two businesses. The sales presentation promised tax preparation and filing, bookkeeping support, and ongoing tax guidance. The salesperson even claimed they had access to over 6,000 tax write-off codes compared with approximately 600 used by a regular accountant. I already had an accountant, but switched based on these representations. As of October 6, 2026, my 2025 taxes remain unfiled. My experience with my initial tax advisor, Lloyd, was particularly frustrating. During a call when I tried to ask questions, he told me to stop talking, referenced the recorded line, and said he was not supposed to be doing this for me. I was left confused about why assistance seemed to be treated as a favor when I had paid for tax services and guidance. After months without resolution, I requested another advisor. The replacement instructed me to manually delete or exclude every transaction across my connected accounts because the information was not appearing correctly in their system. With two businesses and a substantial volume of transactions, this was not a practical solution. I explained that and was told the issue would be escalated to IT. I never received a follow-up or workable resolution. On October 6, I called to request cancellation and a full refund. I was transferred around and told the appropriate staff were busy and that a high-priority case would be submitted. When I asked about my refund, the representative pointed to the fact that I had attended several appointments. Attending appointments does not resolve my complaint: my taxes remain unfiled, the transaction issue remains unresolved, and I have not received the substantive guidance promised during the sale. I am requesting a full refund, cancellation without renewal, and secure delivery of all my records so I can move forward with another preparer. Based on my experience, the sales promises were strong, but the follow-through was deeply disappointing. I cannot recommend this service.






















