I highly recommend hiring John for MA state and federal tax returns. We live in Somerville and found him randomly as we drove by his office. He has now been preparing our complicated tax returns for over 10 years and we've never seen a mistake. Yes, his consultation time is limited during the tax filing season, but he and his team are busy getting all our returns done on time! I appreciate his prompt turnarounds and accurate work.
About
Costello Tax Associates is a leading accounting firm delivering comprehensive accounting, tax and advisory services to business owners, executives and professionals. Our team provides personalised tax planning, payroll, cash-flow management, financial reporting, estate and business planning, valuations, QuickBooks support and secure document services.
Reviews
Based on 38 Google reviews
Unprofessional and unresponsive. He would only email my ex when we were filing jointly and not copy me in the emails even after I repeatedly asked him to. There have always been errors but we stayed with him for years. Why?? If he’s too busy to return calls or review forms for errors he needs to delegate to his staff. How hard is that? Honestly I think he needs to retire. Reading other reviews on yelp, it sounds like his best years are behind him.
I was referred to Costello Tax Associates by family, who have used their services for years and always spoke highly of them. Unfortunately, my experience was completely different. Communication was extremely poor from the start, and I struggled to get any updates or responses. I later realized that my taxes were never even filed, which is a serious issue. I attempted multiple follow-ups and still received no response. Overall, very unprofessional and disappointing experience. I would not recommend their services.
TLDR: Unresponsive, not accurate, rude, and would have cost us thousands. This was the worst tax experience of my life. John was very short via email if he replied at all. In addition: 1) He made an error on our HSA contributions that only we found. When pointed out all he did was send an updated return and no acknowledgement. 2) He did not enter the cost basis correctly on Employee Stock Transactions and if we did not point it out it would have cost us thousands of extra $ in taxes. No apology or explanation just updated the return. 3) He never confirmed when the return was filed. While we were out of the country on April 15th he would not respond to emails. When we finally got a hold of him on the phone he said he receives too many emails to reply and this is how he does business. I would not use him unless you have a very simple return and trust that it is right without combing through many pages of returns with no help from John.
This was by far the best CPA experience I've ever had. I will be bringing my business and any prospective customers here who need support and trust in someone who cares about the people walking in the door. 5 stars easily!






















