Peter represented me recently. He did his job flawlessly. It was a very easy-going experience, and he me wrote very thoughtful emails explaining what was going on and what time expect. He also represented me for exactly the price that was originally quoted. Great work, Peter. I would recommend you to a friend in a heartbeat
About
Keffer Hirschauer LLP is an Indianapolis-based law firm specialising in criminal defence, civil rights and family law. Our litigation-focused team pairs courtroom experience with meticulous case preparation and strategic advocacy in complex litigation. We draw on prosecution and public defence experience to anticipate strategies, seek favourable outcomes and protect client rights.
Reviews
Based on 275 Google reviews
We cannot thank our attorney, Myekeal Wynn, enough for the way he handled our case. From the very beginning, he treated us with respect, honesty, and compassion during one of the hardest times in our lives. He took the time to truly understand the situation—not just the legal side, but the human side—and that meant everything to our family. His communication was clear, his preparation was thorough, and he never made us feel like “just another case.” Because of his dedication and willingness to advocate fully, we were given an outcome that gives our family hope moving forward. If you are looking for an attorney who is not only knowledgeable but genuinely cares, I cannot recommend him enough.
Review for Attorney Peter Capofari – 5/16/26 My experience with Peter as my public defender has been deeply disappointing, especially considering the seriousness of what led to my charges. On August 4th, 2024, while working as a police officer, I was ambushed in my patrol vehicle. That incident changed my life. I developed severe PTSD and panic attacks—something I had never experienced before. One of those episodes caused me to black out on my living room floor. My children got out of the house, and I was charged with Neglect of a Dependent. I immediately sought therapy and counseling. PTSD is invisible, and I had no idea what was happening to me. When first responders arrived, I was taken to the Daleville/Salem Township Fire Department. I stood in front of roughly 13 first responders who did not check my vitals. I could barely stand, was drooling, and later learned my blood pressure was 211/128. The fire chief later apologized and even asked me to help with training, which I agreed to. But throughout my court case, I have felt completely alone. I have done the research, gathered the evidence, and pushed the case forward myself. Peter rarely communicated, did not advocate for me, and did not fight for a fair outcome. A close friend of mine—an experienced prosecutor and attorney—reviewed my case and described Peter as “unmotivated,” said he was shocked Peter was accepting the plea offer because it was not fair to me, and even said he believed Peter should be steamrolling the state in a case like this. I understand he is a public defender, but that does not excuse a lack of effort or care. Every client deserves fairness. I am sharing this because I don’t want anyone else to feel as alone or unsupported as I have. I am preparing a formal complaint and will update this review as things move forward. Legal Disclaimer: Everything stated above reflects my personal opinions and personal experiences only. These statements are not presented as verified facts, legal conclusions, or assertions of wrongdoing, and others may have different experiences. — Kyle 5/14/26
Tom and his associates have been representing my parents on a family law matter. They have been extremely supportive, communicative, and knowledgeable about a complicated matter and have made my family feel much better about the process. As someone in the legal field myself, I greatly appreciate the firm's excellent services and would recommend them to anyone!
I paid $2,000 to this firm to pursue a sentence modification while I was incarcerated. At the beginning, I spoke with the attorney I hired a few times (Bradley Keffer). He instructed me to write letters, have my family write letters, and gather letters of support from people in my community. I did everything that was asked of me. My family did everything that was asked of them. We spent significant time gathering those materials because we believed my case was being actively worked on. After that, I never heard from the attorney I hired again. Not once. For over a year, I received no updates, no communication, and no information about my case. My family repeatedly attempted to contact the firm and obtain answers but got nowhere. Then, after I was released from prison, moved to another state, and obtained a brand-new phone number, I unexpectedly received a call from a completely different attorney at the firm, not the attorney I hired. During that call, I was told that my sentence modification had been denied and that the firm had been unable to contact me while I was incarcerated. That explanation has never made sense to me. I was housed at the same correctional facility for years. During the time this firm represented me, I remained in the same facility, in the same housing unit, with the same counselor. The counselor through whom I had previously communicated with my attorney was still assigned to me. My family was actively attempting to communicate with the firm as well. What I still cannot understand is how the firm supposedly could not contact me while I was incarcerated, yet somehow managed to obtain and call my brand-new phone number after I was released and living in another state. To this day, I have no idea how they even got that number. What concerns me most is what I later found when I reviewed the court record. Because my offense was classified as violent, a request to modify sentence would have been required before any modification could even be considered. However, after reviewing the court record, I was unable to find any request to modify sentence filing at all. I paid over $2,000 for a sentence modification. I gathered every letter and document that was requested. My family participated and cooperated. I waited over a year without hearing a word from the attorney I hired. Then I was told my modification had been denied, only to later discover that I could not find any record showing that the required filing had ever been made. The reality is that I paid more than $2,000 and, based on the court record available to me, I have been unable to find evidence that the filing I hired this firm to pursue was ever filed. I paid for legal representation and a sentence modification effort and have nothing to show for it. I have since requested answers, documentation, and a refund of my money. No one has responded. The complete lack of communication, accountability, and willingness to address these concerns has been incredibly frustrating. I trusted this firm, followed every instruction I was given, and paid thousands of dollars for a service that, based on everything I have been able to verify, was never performed. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this firm.






















