The Law Office of Casey Tuggle, P.C.

Morgan Merrill

8 months ago

We hired Casey in April 2025 for an adoption. From the beginning, there was a consistent lack of communication and clarity regarding our case and paperwork. Our initial consultation with Casey was canceled last minute and reassigned to a paralegal, yet we were still charged the full consultation fee. I had to call multiple times to ensure that fee was properly credited toward our retainer. Throughout our case, we experienced long periods without responses and were told that “it’s very rare to get a same-day response of any substance.” We have worked with multiple attorneys over the years and have never had difficulty receiving at least same-day acknowledgment from a legal team member. During our consultation, the paralegal set expectations that Casey later described as “unrealistic.” There appeared to be ongoing miscommunication between the paralegal and Casey, which left us repeatedly filling information gaps and restating details before we could move forward. We also learned midway through the process that the Casey Tuggle Law Office does not operate from a physical office location open to clients. Calls are not transferred, and messages are simply taken, leaving you to wait and hope for a return call or email. The only time progress was made was when we were able to get someone on the phone—if the call wasn’t canceled. Had we not called and emailed multiple times each week, I believe our case would have been significantly delayed. To be fair, the adoption was finalized in about three months, which is relatively fast. However, I strongly believe the timeline was expedited because of our own persistence and constant follow-up. The stress caused by poor communication and lack of responsiveness placed a significant strain on our daily lives. The most concerning issue occurred after finalization. Our personal information and official court documents were mailed to Vital Statistics without tracking. After three months of being told they had not received the paperwork, on December 3, 2025, we were informed the documents were likely “lost” in the mail and that we were responsible for obtaining new certified copies and mailing them ourselves. The refiling fees alone totaled $1,000. We had only been provided one official copy, leaving us without backups. When I expressed concern, Casey offered to obtain additional documents and mail them “soon.” However, by February, we had still received no response from anyone in the office. As a result, we had to hire another attorney to obtain the necessary documents. To add, I was not the client, my husband was. Yet anytime my husband called or emailed they completely ignored him and only responded to my emails and calls and only sent updates to myself and not my husband who was the client. We have since hired Stearns-Montgomery & Proctor and have experienced consistent updates, inclusion in the process, and weekly communication.Read more

Leo De Jesus

2 weeks ago

I highly recommend The Law Office of Casey Tuggle and their team. Going through a divorce is never easy, but having the right attorney made a difficult process much more manageable. From the beginning, they were professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and always took the time to explain things clearly and make sure I understood my options. I truly felt like they had my best interests in mind throughout the entire process. I especially appreciated their patience, communication, and ability to keep things moving forward even when things became stressful or complicated. I’m grateful for the guidance and representation I received and for helping me reach the other side of this chapter. If you’re looking for a divorce attorney who genuinely cares about their clients and knows how to navigate the process, I would absolutely recommend The Law Office of Casey Tuggle.Read more

Kim Brooks

3 months ago

I cannot say enough wonderful things about attorney Casey and paralegal Samantha. They guided me through one of the most stressful and emotional experiences of my life with a level of professionalism, compassion, and dedication that went far beyond what I ever expected. They are the kind of people you want standing beside you when everything feels uncertain. Thanks to their hard work, I was able to move forward with peace of mind and a positive outcome for my family. I am deeply grateful for everything they did. If you need representation from people who truly care and will fight for you with skill and integrity, Casey and Samantha are the ones you want in your corner.Read more

paul pasebay

2 months ago

After fighting for custody of my daughter for years, I finally won custody, and the outcome was actually more than I ever expected or hoped for. Casey was direct, honest, and straight to the point from day one. She never sugarcoated anything or told me what I wanted to hear—she told me what I needed to hear and always kept the focus on what was best for my daughter. She went above and beyond my expectations throughout the entire case. She was prepared, knowledgeable, and fought hard for me and my daughter. When everything was finally over, the outcome she was able to achieve was better than I had expected going into it. After such a long and difficult fight, I can’t put into words how grateful I am for everything she did for my family. If you’re looking for an attorney who will be honest with you, stand her ground, and truly fight for you, I couldn’t recommend her more. Absolutely deserving of 5 stars.Read more

Kayla Stringer

5 months ago

Casey and her team made my uncontested divorce process much easier than I expected. They were responsive, professional and always kept communication open throughout everything. What stood out most was that even after my divorce was finalized, they still took the time to answer questions and help with concerns I had afterward. I truly appreciated their support and highly recommend Casey and her team. 🖤Read more